Books on tape. Is it the same?
I've been reading, well, forever it feels like. As a kid, I gobbled up library books, as a teen, most of my allowance was spent in the book aisle at the corner drugstore. But oddly enough, other than a second-hand set someone gave me of fairytales for my oldest daughter (which we never even opened) I've never had any books-on-tape, or audio books as they I understand they are called now. Until yesterday.
My youngest daughter finally (whew) caught the Harry Potter bug. She walked in with that two-foot talk stack of hardback books and told me she was ready for us to to read them together. Thrilled as I was, I knew that meant I'd be doing most of the reading. Well, big bad secret time... I don't like to read aloud. I read, well, in clumps. Paragraphs at a time. My daughter is the same, so reading aloud is challenging.
But I wasn't willing to give up the fun of sharing the amazing world of Harry Potter with my daughter. My mother, who'd become something of an addict, told me to get the books on CD. Hmm... okay, pricey but worth a try.
Wow! Its like a different world.
Its not the same as reading a book. The images aren't flashing in my head, I'm not falling into the story like I do when I read it silently, or even aloud. But its wild fun anyhow! My daughter is loving it.
This led me to search out what other books are on CD. Did you know Blazes can be listened to? Whoa... Now hearing Harry in a wizards duel is one thing... listening to a love scene? Definitely a different world. I have a friend who reads certain scenes out loud to her husband... gotta wonder if it'd have the same effect.
So, I have to ask. Do you listen to audio books? And have you ever listened to a Blaze, or a hotter book, on audio? Details are good *g* I'm so curious and might have to go shopping again.



















Great Topic!
I know folks who listen to books, but I never have. I can't bring myself to do it -- I did listen to a sample of one of my books online and had to shut it off -- it freaked me out, because the woman narrating was sort of "acting" the male lead with her voice, lowering, etc and is just SO didn't work for me (and I see from reviews that while people liked the book, they didn't like the narration, either). I was glad to see my other audio editions had a different narrator, but I was too apprehensive to listen to them.
As a reader, I just don't get into it, I guess because I'm not much of a listener, anyway, even with music. As an author, it bothered me a little, because apparently my books are doing well enough in ebook and audio that I've had two in a row come out in audio, which my ed told me is not the case with all, since they only choose a few each month, so I am VERY happy for that, but since my little experience listening to my own, I now realize a lot of what a reader/listener experiences of MY book is through the narrator, and that's a little scary to me! LOL
Sam
Ack
I hear you, Sam! That would be just, well, freaky. I'm like you, very non-audial. I use music to write by, but its more of a... wall. Once I put my headphones on, I'm able to block out all the other sounds. Even though I set up a playlist for each book, its more for sub-conscious effect than anything else if that makes sense. Blocking out audial sounds is the easiest thing for me (and unfortunately for my kids LOL).
I have never listened to an
I have never listened to an audio book. I think my attention would wander like it does when I listen to the radio.
Ya gotta wonder
For those of us who are voracious readers, does it totally change the experience by listening? I know one couple who get all the books they want in audio because the husband hates to read (gasp). It seems to work for them, but other than the Harry Potter experience, I doubt I'd be able to listen to others. This is more like... well, a part of the whole wonder that JK Rowling created LOL. I definitely would be like Sam if I heard my book in audio, a little freaked.
Agreed
I know people who listen in the car, and women who listen while doing housekeeping, laundry, etc to pass the time, and a friend of mine who is legally blind really enjoys listening to books (she can read, but needs special glasses and big print, not always available). So I can see a lot of advantages, but I don't think I would absorb as much listening. I don't know why, I just don't think I would. Like Estella, I think my mind would wander and I'd miss stuff...
Sam
I wonder
if it really comes back to that learning style thing? Visual, audio or kinesthetic? I'm so strongly visual, I see the scenes as I write them (and read them) but all I get when I listen is a blank image.
Makes you wonder how the kinesthetic learners would best experience our books? ooooooohhhhhhh
LOL
Well, that is learning by doing, right? I think I'm that sort (snicker...)
Sam
ROFL
The best way to learn, huh?
Ah yes...
But I suppose we have digressed, LOL. See what happens when they leave us all alone?
I know you're thinking of Johnny Depp right now, aren't you? *EG*
Sam
Hot "Listens" as Opposed to Hot "Reads"?
Hi Tawny!! Fun topic! When I was commuting an hour or more to work, I'd listen to audio books. My favorite was Diana Gabaldon's Outlander. But it wasn't the same as reading it, and I found the reader's voice (a woman) a little annoying when she tried to do the hero's Scottish brogue. But it was still fun, I still have the tape, and I still pop it in and listen to it every now and then.
My book, Flyboy was made into an audiobook, so I did download it, but...I have no idea how to transfer it to an MP3 player or to my computer so that I can actually listen to it. So I have it, but it's floating out there in cyberspace somewhere. But eHarlequin had a demo that you could listen to, and let me tell you...it was a screaming howl to hear my book being read aloud! I laughed until tears streamed down my face. It was thrilling...a little embarrassing...totally weird to hear this woman with a low, seductive voice reading Angel's lines. The demo ended before it got to any really hot scenes, and I'm just dying to figure out how to listen to it...I want to see my husband's face when I play it privately for him, LOL!
Oooooh you're brave!!
I don't know if I'd be able to listen to mine, Karen LOL. But I'll bet my husband would... what a great idea.
Hmm... finding the download. Do you know where you downloaded it to in your hardddrive? If you use iTunes, you can go to import, find where you downloaded it and click, and it'll save it to your iTunes library :-)
Turning the page
I also have resisted the audio-book experience. I think I'd miss the whole reading process; holding the book in my hand, smelling the fresh pages and the sound of the turning page. Plus, where would the chocolate stain go? I can immediately turn to a really good scene in any book on my shelf by looking for the chocolate stain (or sometimes the Cheeto stain). I love it when the story sucks you in so much you forget to lick your fingers before turning!
-Tasha
I love it when the story
I love it when the story sucks you in so much you forget to lick your fingers before turning!
This may be the best description of deep reading I've ever come across!
Sam
OMG how perfect
Tasha, you summed up the reading experience so well :-D
I love it!
I love listening to books!
I'm an auditory learner, so I love listening to books. I listen while I drive. I listen to books while I run. I tried to listen to music while running, but it made me feel anxious, but a book...an excellent way to occupy the mind while torturing the body.
I don't usually watch television--I listen to it while I do something else.
Great topic!
Jeannie
Ahhhhh
That is so cool, Jeannie! I'm always impressed with how people learn, and auditory is so beyond my abilities that I'm in awe LOL. So... have you listened to a Blaze? Or hotter books? It seems like it would be such a different experience.
I just found out that Blaze
I just found out that Blaze are audio last week! I'm going to try to figure out how to download to my MP3 and give it a try.
Blaze audio
lol Jeannie - I just found out today when I was talking to my editor :-) I had nooo clue.
Jeannie, if you figure how
Jeannie, if you figure how to do it, please let me know! :-)
Will do...first step, find
Will do...first step, find my deeply buried MP3 player. In my husband's desk, I think...
COOL
I'm not a big audio person, but I'd love to try a Blaze on audio. I just get more from an actual book, only because my mind wanders when I'm listening, especially if I'm doing something else and can't devote my entire attention to it. I will say the reader of the Harry Potter audios, is brilliant and has won many awards.
I agree
Jibby, I'm amazed at how easy it is to listen to the Harry Potter books, but like you said, my attention definitely wanders.
I'm ashamed to say, I have no clue if my Blazes are in audio or not... I'm going to look. Then... hmm, well, maybe I'll listen LOL. It would really be interesting. On second thought, I'll get someone elses *g*
One Audio book
I've only listened to one audio book: The Mist by Stephen King and it was in the style of a play, kinda like an old radio serial with sound effects and lots of actors playing the different parts.
Amanda Murphy w/a Jill James
http://www.jilljamesromance.com
Now that I could do
I think that format would be intriguing to listen to, Jill. Defintiely it would require a different mindset than listening to a book being narrated, wouldn't it? What did you think? Was it good?
I have that, Amanda! It was
I have that, Amanda! It was in like, 3-D sound, so if you listened to it with headphones, it sounded like you were in the action! :)
I have listened to the samples of my audiobooks and...they DID have some hot parts sampled. *blush*
But mostly, no, I don't listen to audio books.
M
Read in bed!
www.meganhart.com
Listen to a good book, lately?
My blind friend turned me on to books on tape. Sometimes, it is easier to listen than to read. When I commuted to work, it was the best way to pass the time. Some days, if the book was good, I would sit in my car during lunch because I couldn't wait until the end of the day to hear more. They are also good for tanning, exercising (walking, biking) and when itchy-eye-allergy season starts. Much like a bad author can ruin a good story, a bad reader can ruin a good book. The Harry Potter series has Jim Dale, a former Broadway actor. A really good reader can make a mediocre book good.
I had the book and record combos as a kid and loved them. I found some Disney books and tapes for my son because I loved mine. Turn the page when you hear this sound.... :-)
Jim Dale
I'm seriously blown away at the voices this guy comes up with and the intensity that he is bringing to the story. I didn't think I'd like it much, but my daughter and I sat her, her on my lap, for an hour just listening. The whole time, a little voice in the back of my head kept reminding me that I had things to do. But I knew I couldn't multi-task and listen. I totally lose track and my brain wanders off into lala land LOL.
Turn the page when you hear the sound.... I remember that! Maybe I have heard more than I realized.
I think it depends on who's reading
I also have issues with one gender "acting" the voice of the other. It just sounds weird and yanks me out of the story. And if the person sounds different from the protagonist in age or something, that bothers me. I'd imagine it works better for stuff that has a first person feel and they pick someone who fits the bill closely.
However....I'm a big fan of the Sharpe TV series, so listening to Sharpe's Tiger (a prequel of most of the filmed eps) being read by Sean Bean was AoK with me. Even when he read the woman's voice... Then again, I could listen to him read the phone book.
Jen
http://www.jenlewis.com
Great point
I'll bet the narrator can really make or break an audio book, Jennifer. Like you say, some voices you can listen to say ANYTHING and love it. Others are just freaky.
Audio? Bah Humbug!
My friend gave me 3 audio books as a birthday present. I hated them. Not the stories but, the narration. It's very disturbing to listen to a woman lowering her voice, to try to sound like a man. I'd much rather read a book than listen to someone trying to act out the characters, and changing their voice several times during the narration.
The audio books were older Harlequins by Penny Jordan. I haven't bought any recent audio books, and I just can't imagine a female narrator trying to lower her voice to imitate a sexy Blaze male stud. I'd probably LMAO.
Audio books do have some advantages though. They are good for someone who can't see well or, who have trouble reading. As for me, I'd rather read a book than listen to one. Mads:)
LOL Mads
I just can't wrap my mind around audio and Blaze. Seriously - Harry Potter, well, as much as I adore the books, they are at the core childrens' stories and them being read (or narrated) doesn't ick me out. But a Blaze? I think I'd rather watch it happen than hear it being told to me, expecially if the narrator acts out the voices LOL. I can just imagine the moans of pleasure.
Oh, God...
I hadn't even thought about the moaning... I don't think I could bear it, LOL, listening to that...
I'm with you -- put it in a movie or something, good, but not just the voices, especially when it's just one voice...
And I wondered if it would make any difference if a man read them? Maybe a masculine voice would narrate our books better? It could be the female narration, frankly, that throws things off...
Sam
Snerk!
Sorry, I'm laughing at some of the other comments, about how one might hear Blazes or other "hot" titles read aloud--eek! I have no idea when I would even consider listening to these--my kids are pretty much around when I might consider listening (listening to a book might be convenient when I'm trying to do other things, like cooking or laundry or that sort of thing), and I'm already wondering about when they're going to start to want to read the physical books I read. Forget the audio!
As for other genres of books on tape, haven't really tried--I can understand it might be cool to listen to some together as a family, like the HPs when my kids are slightly older. I really prefer reading to listening (and even to watching--book vs. movie thing), and the thought of all that having to pay attention doesn't really appeal to me. So we've only listened to those little kids' books, with the beeps for page turns :)
My brother has even read a couple of audio books, and I haven't even listened to the ones he's voiced. How horrible of me!
Definitely an aquired taste
Fedora, I prefer reading to listening myself. For whatever reason, sitting still only doing one thing (reading) is easier with a book in my hands than with a book on CD, I've found.
How cool, though, that your brother narrates audio books!!
I've tried..
I've tried audio books a few times, but it always seems that the narrator goes at a different cadence than I do when I read, so I have a hard time following. Although, I have to admit I'm curious about listening to a Blaze. I imagine the narrator could make or break those. Hhmm... :-D
Let me know
If you do listen to a Blaze, I HAVE to hear what you think. I mean, talk about books tat cadence and rythm are key LOLOL
Harry Potter books on Cd
I loved!!!! the Harry Potter books on CD.
My daughter who is dyslexic really excelled by listening to books and following along in the book. She listened to all Harry Potter books. I also love Jim Dale and all of the voices. I just started another book on tape I have an hour commute each way. I like them
Short commute
Hmm, Beth. Maybe thats a part of it, my commute is pretty short (its not a long hallway *g*). Next long drive we do, though, I'm going to give an audio book a try and see how that goes.
My youngest is just getting into the HP thing - the moves were "too scary" for her before, but now she's driving her older sister crazy with the HP mania. We've watched the movies and I admit it, when she told me she wanted me to read the series to her (omg those are looooong books to read aloud) I jumped on the 'lets try audio' bandwagon out of desperation LOL. But it has turned into a fun adventure.
Late to the party...
Once again, but...
I actually love listening to books on tape, especially in the car. I'm a terribly jumpy reader, so listening to the book forces me to really delve into the language and the setting. I like podcasts for the same reason. I'm listening to "Pride and Prejudice" right now...well, not right now, but you get the idea. ;)
Basically, it's a way of slowing down as a reader. In an era when I can blow through 2-3 books a week without really immersing myself in one, listening helps me immerse. Never listened to a Blaze, though. No way.
Better late than never
I wonder if some books are just better suited to audio than others? Pride and Prejudice, Harry Potter... what are some others?
I think thats a great point about having to slow down. I hear you on blowing through the books, but its such a different experience to have to focus and listen to them.