Enduring Heroines

ShirleyJump's picture

A few days ago, a local newspaper interviewed me (and several other writers) about "enduring heroines," meaning those heroines from novels who stay with us for a long, long time (you can read the story here ; it came out in today's paper; don't ask me where they got that awful pic of me). The ones we remember long after we close the book, because they have impacted us in some way or another. The second half of the question was why, and what lesson these classic heroines can impart to today's readers and young women.

My answer was Jane Eyre, though I could have picked so many, because I read voraciously when I was younger. I think all those heroines shaped me a little, in one way or another. Nancy Drew for her intrepid, plucky, "can go anywhere the boys can go and be smarter and better than them" spirit, Scarlett O'Hara for her strength, resourcefulness (even if I didn't always agree with all her choices), and her belief that no matter how bad things were today, tomorrow would be better. Hester from The Scarlet Letter for refusing to cowtow to her circumstances, for being strong in the face of incredible societal pressure, and for refusing to be labeled, even when she had to wear the brand of an adulteress.

I chose Jane Eyre because I think she's one of those quiet heroines, one of the ones you least expect to jump out at you. She's quiet, reserved, almost shy in a way. Jane Eyre is a classic Beauty and the Beast story, but this particular Beauty is not exactly cover model worthy, nor is she the singing, plucky Belle of the Disney version. Jane is an understated, reserved but strong woman who says what she means, and had a way of slicing to the core of a person with one sentence or two. She can see past the gruff exterior of Mr. Rochester to the wounded man he is inside, and rather than baby that, she shows him she expects more out of him--expects him to step up and become the man he should be. She's strong, principled and unforgettable.

I've reread Jane Eyre several times, and seen the movie versions more times than I can count. Every time, I see something new in the book or movie that surprises me, a turn of phrase that stands out because of its brilliance in saying so much in just a few words.

So my question to you today is the same one they asked me--what classic heroine is your favorite? Why does she stay with you, and what lessons does she teach?

Shirley

Nell

Anyone ever read My Friend Flicka? I read it a million times when I was a kid. I loved the horse story, but I was also fascinated by the story between the parents, Nell and Rob. For a book I was reading from the children's section of the library, the details about their marriage and, in particular, Nell's feelings about being a wife and mother and a woman were so complex and honest. At the time, I'm sure some of it went over my head and some of it confused me, but I've often thought about Nell and Rob and how their love endured but changed.

Interesting topic, Shirley!

You would think...

Considering how much I loved horses as a little girl, I would have read that one, but I never did. I read all the "Misty of Chiconteague" books, though (the horses are rounded up on my birthday and I have always wanted to go there and see that some year). But someday, I will definitely have to read Flicka.

Shirley

New York Times and USA Today Bestselling Author
www.shirleyjump.com
THE WELL, coming in September
www.ajwhitten.com

Fun post, Shirley, and I

Fun post, Shirley, and I don't think it's possible to take a bad picture of you!

As a child, I adored the Laura Ingalls Wilder series, and reread them several times. I loved Laura's spunk, and how much she loved her family. Her adventures could just as easily apply to young girls today (provided they could tear themselves away from thier laptops for long enough...you girls know who I'm talking about!), and the lessons she learned are timeless.

Ooh, definitely!

We just read these as a family this past year, and we still talk about the different books and Laura's adventures!

interesting !

I know I should probably pick a french character but honestly no french heroin comes to my mind right now !! I know shame on me ;-)
Elizabeth Bennett is my pick. Of course it helps that I read Pride and Prejudice more than a dozen times but really she's a heroin impossible to forget. I love both her strenght and her vulnerability and the fact that she was humble enough to redeem herself.