Karen Foley
Lynn Raye Harris
Ellen Hartman
Diana Holquist
Samantha Hunter
Shirley Jump
Dee Tenorio
Jeannie Watt
Welcome Guest Blogger Jeannie Watt!
What makes a cowboy such good hero material?
Not long ago, I would have answered that question with a simple “most everything,” but that was before Sam, who was working on Pick Me Up (an excellent read), asked me some research questions about cowboys. Suddenly I needed to come up with more than a two-word reply. I had just finished writing my September Superromance The Horseman’s Secret and had started the sequel The Brother Returns, both of which feature cowboy heroes, but I hadn’t really analyzed what makes a cowboy a cowboy and not a city guy in boots.
I live in a remote ranching community in northern Nevada and I write my heroes based on my own experiences and the people I know. And there was my answer—the people I know. So, in my head, I lined up my sexiest cowboy neighbors and started analyzing attributes. These are the “makes a cowboy a cowboy” attributes I came up with:
Self Discipline People from generational ranch families have a code of conduct that was originated and maintained as a means of survival. Ranching was not easy in the early days and it took exceptional individuals to succeed at it. Self-discipline was very important and people practiced it in most arenas of life. These codes of conduct are still valued and passed down, even though they are not so necessary for survival now. Ranch kids have self-discipline and manners and they tend to hang onto these qualities when they grow into adulthood. Is there anything better than an honestly polite guy?
Strong… Cowboys are usually unpretentious, honest, open (after they get to know you)—but they have an edge. It’s not necessarily a dark side, but more of a hard side. There are often unpleasant chores to be done on a ranch and if a guy showed open emotion every time he had to put down an animal or had to doctor a seriously injured one, well, he’d be emoting rather frequently. So a cowboy does what has to be done without a lot of hoopla. I think cowboys cultivate this hard side in order to protect those they love. If they break down, then who is going to be strong?
Silent… Cowboys are often quiet when you first get to know them. Sometimes it’s shyness (think Gary Cooper), but other times it’s because reticence allows them to get a read on you. You speak, they answer, they’re friendly and polite, but you don’t have clue what’s going on in their heads. And don’t we all love the challenge of finding out what makes a reticent guy tick?
Type, or "Sense of Self" Many cowboys are provincial, but they don’t necessarily feel inferior because of it. If they don’t know what you’re talking about, they’ll either be quiet and listen or ask questions. I’ve rarely seen a cowboy pretend to know something he doesn’t. Cowboys are quite aware of the fact that they can do things and understand things outsiders can’t. They are secure in their own culture, and I think that’s why they aren’t afraid to ‘not know’ things. Real cowboys have a refreshing lack of pretensions.
Cultural Pride A cowboy recognizes another cowboy and appreciates his unique heritage. One thing that amuses me is how secretly intolerant cowboys are of people pretending to be cowboys. I think it’s almost a matter of “Hey, I’m not pretending to be a banker, so why are you pretending to be a cowboy?” But most of them would never voice this aloud to the offender. If you aren’t born to a ranching or cowboy family, you have to work hard to be considered a cowboy and not a wannabe.
Dress Code (Hey, the right outfit for the right occasion is important.) Cowboys are very conscious of the way they dress. (Dare I say vain?) Go-to-town clothes are important. They have to be neat—clean jeans and a pressed shirt. For public functions, like rodeos, many cowboys will wear jewelry—rawhide bracelets, fancy hatbands, silver conchos on their top shirt button, or a concho pin on their wild rag (scarf). They often wear vests and belts with large sterling silver buckles, two-tone boots that no one sees the tops of. So, on the one hand they are very down to earth guys who work in a dirty environment, and on the other, they are men who polish their silver jewelry and tie a silk scarf around their neck for dress occasions. Cowboys tend to analyze one another’s gear and outfits. They may not say anything, but they often notice. Also, buckaroos will wear pale pink or floral scarves without flinching. Now there’s a man who’s comfortable with himself.
Not all cowboys are heroes, of course. I know alcoholic cowboys, asinine cowboys, blustering cowboys, dishonest cowboys, but, as a whole, the cowboy culture seems to have more good guys than bad. Thank goodness.
So what do you think makes a cowboy a cowboy and not a city boy in boots? And (heaven forbid) do you think readers are going to tire of cowboy heroes?
Share your comments with me and you’ll be entered for a chance to win a copy of The Horseman’s Secret and one of my braided horsehair bracelets (which are honest to goodness cowboy finery). You must be a registered user of the Exploding Cigars blog to enter. I’ll draw one winner at the end of the day.
Jeannie
You can learn more about me and my books at my website .

Hi Jeannie! I had this whole
Hi Jeannie!
I had this whole thing typed out, and I got all excited thinking about those cowboy butts, I accidently hit the wrong button! So Im starting over lol
To me a cowboy is a hardworking man who isn't afraid to get his hands dirty, and not afraid to kick off those dusty boots at the end of the day and just have a good time.
He is honest, has a great smile, knows who he is and not afraid to express himself. He knows what he wants, and not afraid to work for it. He has a great drawl oh baby, and oh no here I go again getting worked up!
Two famous people I think of when I start thinkin' cowboys is John Wayne and Trace Adkins. Gimme some of that badonkidonk anyday whoa nellie!
I seriously doubt that cowboy stories will cease to exist. We ladies need our country boys!
~ Wendy
I agree
Amen and ditto to everything you said Wendy! LOL
Cowboys
A city boy just can't sit a horse the way a true cowboy does. No matter how hard they try. They also can't work a cattle ranch, rope or ride herd. I wouldn't even want to see them try. Or maybe I would, just to get a good laugh.
As for books about cowboys going by the wayside? I sure hope not. Cowboys have always had a certain ruggedness about them, that makes a woman want to cuddle up with them on a cold winter night. Reading about them, makes you want one for your very own.
Thanks for taking the time to blog with us. Have a great weekend. Mads:)
OH OH OH Cowboys!
Well, I guess I should admit that I ran right to "add new comment" before even reading the above. That's how excited I was! LOL
I'm from Iowa and we don't have "cowboys" we have farmer's and farmer's kids. So I'm using them as my example for cowboys since I've never met a real one. There is nothing hotter than a man in tight fitting wranglers and a Stetson... wooo-eeee! And those western dress shirts with the pearly buttons... hubba hubba!
As for what separates cowboys and city boys.... cowboys are a little dusty and rugged and manly smelling. And when it's shower time, they clean up really nice. A city boy, he's just a poser. There's no dust, no sweat on his brow, no creases on his jeans, his hat is stiff, and his boots are too damn shiney.
**fanning self** Give me a cowboy anyday, or a farmer.. but keep those posing city boys away.
I'll agree with you on those
I'll agree with you on those farmer cowboys Mendy! I dig those coveralls...weird probably, but I think they are sexy when they have one of them cowboy hats on too !
Great description
I like your description of cowboy vs city boy, Mendy. Amen!
cowboys
I've never met a real cowboy myself so maybe that is part of the big attraction - my fantasy cowboy will have all of the attributes you mentioned above. And, no, I don't think they'll ever go out of style. And who can resist men in cowboy hats and boots (okay maybe some chaps too lol).
Oh....MY HEART!!!
You have no idea how much I love cowboys. I will buy and read just about anything to read about those sexy guys. In Tracey Land, they are all honest, sexy, tight a$$, gorgeous eyes, and the voice....oh gotta love the southern drawl. I went to visit a friend in TX and was so excited to see honest to goodness cowboys. She must have thought I was an idiot, the way I was staring and shocked that they really walk around in "cowboy" clothes everywhere they go. I just don't see things like that around here. I was so drawn to the voice and she says I have hillbilly love. lol If my hubby would let me, I'd up and move us tomorrow;) I could barely get back on the plane and was just in awe. I'm just not meant for this boring place called Indiana:( Not to mention, I almost stole one of her goats. I even had her name it after me, since she's loud and likes her food. lol If that isn't cowboy love, I don't know what it.
LOL
There is something special about southern cowboys Tracey! The southern drawl gets me every time! ;-) Yee-Haw!
I'm a Yankee...
...so the Southern drawl has never done it for me. Not that I'd turn one down if it came packaged with a yummy cowboy, though! LOL!
Okay, I just gotta say...
Being the Texas friend of jibby2, that I have had..ooops...I mean seen, my share of cowboys and let me tell you, without a doubt, they are DEFINITELY all they are cracked up to be!!! And if you can find them (not hard to do) just a little on the rough & dirty side, you are a woman with a smile for daaaaays.
D@mn, now I gotta go take a cold shower!
Mmmmm...cowboys!
Yum!! I like cowboy stories. I like your definitions for a real cowboy, Ms. Jeannie!
I think one important quality of a cowboy hero is that he doesn't mind the "silence" of the land. Sounds silly, I know, but living in CO and meeting real cowboys has made that bit hit home!
I will never tire of cowboy heroes!! Never, never, never, never! DH even agreed to wear cowboy boots for our wedding. Yum! And my dad went and bought boots and a hat for my wedding. Yep, that's when the tears came, let me tell you. Mmm....cowboys!!
Hi Cathy
I agree, cowboys have a special bond with the land, and they appreciate the importance of nature! That is so cool that your dad bought boots and a hat for your wedding!
Cowboy butts drive me nuts! ;-)
I can say I will never never ever tire of cowboy heroes!!! ;-)
I grew up in Oklahoma and I really miss the real cowboys. I now live in a small town in Indiana, and there are not many cowboys in my area, but plenty of city boy in boots! LOL
I have had a thing for cowboys as long as I can remember! While all my friends in grade school were in love with Shaun Cassidy, I was in love with John Wayne! LOL
What can I say, I am a cowgirl at heart.
I worked with a guy that wore cowboy boots and huge belt buckles and he thought that made him a cowboy! NOT!!! LOL
And a cowboy with a southern drawl. OMG!!!
Is it hot in here or is it just me??? LOL
You guys are all nuts!
Of course, so am I! I'm a cowboy lover, too. I like the silent, brooding types the best. Not sure what it is...maybe just the mystery. Love the slow drawls, too...the ones that promise they'll take their time in...um, other areas, too! :)
I'm going to have to agree with those who've mentioned the farmers, too. I've never actually met a cowboy, but I'm from Wisconsin, so I know all about farmers. Now, I don't get into the guys in the overalls who smell like barn. I'm more into the shirtless guys who throw around hay bails without any effort!
Since someone brought up Trace Adkins, I'm going to bring up Eric Church and his song "Guys Like Me". That's the kind of guy I like!!! Boots, hardworking, jeans, ballcaps...
Big sigh. Man, I could talk about this all day long!! :)
Hmmm...
It isn't just how well they fill out their jeans (although that certainly doesn't hurt ;)), but I think of cowboys as being very independent and able to do just about anything themselves. While a city boy (or girl--I'm definitely in this category!) would call in the experts to fix the leaking roof or repair the fence or tend to a sick animal, I imagine that a cowboy would jump in and do these things himself. (I'm sure there are less competent cowboys, but I imagine the majority to be self assured (that sense of self you mentioned) and ready to try.)
And no, I don't think the appeal of cowboys is going away any time soon!
A cowboy story. I just love
A cowboy story. I just love those! ooh, and those pictures on your blog. Who can resist? I think the true cowboys have more strength and tend to not take things as much for granted as a city boy in boots. I don't think ranching is easy and they have to work harder for what they have so they tend to appreciate it more.
Hey Jeannie!
Welcome to Cigars! You really are the cowboy expert! For anyone who hasn't looked yet, Jeannie has a whole bunch o' stuff on her blog about cowboys, and I know I am eternally grateful for her help -- Brett would not have been the man he is without her. :)
I have never met a cowboy either, so Jeannie's help and expertise was invaluable to me writing Pick Me Up -- if you read the reader letter inside, you'll see her noted there for that reason. Though technically, Brett was a rancher -- he owned his business -- which is really the most interesting thing IMO -- the cowboy who really is as business savvy as any CEO (and of course, we all like the opposite type as well, the business guy who can change out of his suit and roll up his sleeves... we want it all, don't we? LOL I suppose I'm biased -- my husband worked with horses for a long time, and he has that cowboy way, but he's also a city guy...) I think I like the blend of both, which is how Brett was born.
The thing that was most important to me as a writer was realizing, as you say Jeannie, that cowboys are not the stereotype, and that there are many different layers and nuances to cowboys, and even that different states and places have different cowboys -- the clothes they wear are different, such ass Brett wearing a lighter hat in the desert than a cowboy in Montana would, etc. Also that there can be good and bad -- I think Roz Denny Fox did a nice job showing that in her Superromance, Real Cowboys (recommended, as well, if you haven't read it).
But learning about cowboys from Jeannie sure did make me a fan -- before I learned about cowboys, I can't say I was ever all that drawn to cowboy books -- but now I love them! I can't wait to get out west one of these days and see some real cowboys and until then, I'll just have to rely on Jeannie's blogs... ;)
Sam
hiya
I've just recently found the joys of cowboy heroes so I can't add much, I'm still learning lol but I love them
Ashley
Thanks for all the Great Comments!
Wow! It’s so neat to turn my computer on (it’s only 7:30 here) and see so many comments!
Wendy--I think you’re right on the money with a cowboy knowing what he wants and not being afraid to work for it.
Mendy and Sassa-- I’m very familiar with farmers, too. We have some big farms here and I grew up in wheat country. I think the mentality is very similar—the working hard for what you have, and having an appreciation for the land and the animals.
Mads--Great insight about the city boy not sitting a horse the way a cowboy does, and no one mounts a horse the way a cowboy does. It’s just one smooth motion.
Jibby2—I have a goat in The Horseman’s Secret. She only plays a small part, but she has lots of character! Good luck in your quest to move to Texas!
Catslady—Funny you should mention chaps. I have one friend who, when her hubby puts on his chaps to go to work…well, she makes him late. She cannot resist taking those chaps back off.
Cathy H—How could I have forgotten silence of the land? Oh my, but that’s an important part of things. Congrats on having a cowboy boot wedding!
Missy—I love that you had a thing for John Wayne. Me, too, but Jimmy Stewart cowboys were my fave. (I have to admit, I kind of liked Shaun Cassidy, too.)
Fedora—That filling the jeans thing is important, but I so agree that it’s what’s under the hat that counts!
Kim—You’re so right about not taking things for granted. It’s not an easy life and doesn’t pay well in most cases, but there are so many perks from being independent.
Ashley—I’m glad you love cowboys. They really are special.
I am so glad to hear you all love cowboys so much, and as the drawl, we don’t have many drawls here, but they just melt me. I mean MELT me!
Sam—Thanks for inviting me! I’m having a ball.
Jeannie
The Horseman's Secret~Harlequin Superromance~Sept 2007
Gotta love a real cowboy
When I lived a few years in West Texas I really got to have a feel for "real" cowboys. The men who work the range love what they do. They love being outdoors in all kinds of weather. I never met a true cowboy who wasn't unafailingly polite. I used to see them a lot at the dry cleaners I went to. The shirts and jeans they wear to town on Saturday nite for the dances (and most love to dance) were spiffy clean and the jeans were pressed. They kept boots for dancing and boots for working. And I spent a lot of years trying to describe a cowboy walk. Finally decided it defies words.
Great blog Sam, and thanks Jeanne for bringing up the subject of cowboys. Loved The Horseman's Secret and looking forward to the sequel.
Cowboys??
Coming from Britain, I had never met a real cowboy (still haven't) but they never appealed to me.
Donkeycheese mentioned John Wayne and euwww. No thanks.
But then I started reading romances, especially the old categories by Vicki Lewis Thompson and she had a lot of cowboys and I began to see the appeal.
Like you said, Jeannie, there is an innate honesty in cowboys. They don't pretend to be something they're not.
They work hard, they get dirty, they play hard. They're loyal and steadfast. And they protect their women without smothering her. At least, all the good ones do.
Throw in that tight cowboy butt and mmm mmm mmmmmmmmmmmm.
A bunch of us who have posted here are from another board where we trade and talk categories a LOT. And when the subject turns to cowboys there's always a lot of comments.
Being still fairly new to country music, which I realize has nothing to do with cowboys except peripherally, there are some guys that make me think of cowboys: Trace Adkins (oh yeah) but it's more when he sings those ballads about making his woman feel good and that man with the velvet hands, Tim McGraw.
They both emBODY the best characteristics of cowboys!
ani
I love cowboys but hate
I love cowboys but hate country music lol
Ashley
I think you've nailed it
Jeannie, GREAT blog! I think you've nailed the essentials of every hero, though. Cowboy or not. "Regular" heroes may not wear silk scarves around their necks ;) but they have a lot of the same qualities you've listed above. Great, great post.
Kay
Back again.
Roz—The cowboy walk is hard to describe, and I’m glad that you, too, have noticed the level of politeness. It’s one of the things I love most about cowboys. The long lean Wrangler look is second.
Ani—If you want to hear real cowboy music, try Don Edwards, who is a balladeer that sings the old cowboy songs. He has an incredible voice and has researched the stories behind the songs. Michael Martin Murphy and Ian Tyson are also good if you like ballads.
Kay-Lol at the scarf comment, but you’re right. Many heroes have these qualities, sans fancy scarf. You should have seen my husband the first time I tried to put him in a silk scarf. But soon I was making him bigger ones because they are so warm and light in the winter. There is nothing like them.
Jeannie
The Horseman's Secret~Harlequin Superromance~Sept 2007
Love cowboys.
I love cowboys. I think the difference between a real cowboy and a city cowboy is that he knows how to actually do ranch work. He is a hardworking, strong guy who knows how to work a ranch. He isn't just wearing the clothing. Ranching is is vocation.
Cowboys
I love reading cowboy stories! And here in Finland we don't have any cowboys, either.
Cowboys
Well I think real cowboys like the outdoors, they aren't in a rush.
Cowboys
They are some of the hardest working men around. I have alot of respect for them and I heartily agree with your assessment of them. I certainly can't imagine the cowboy hero stories ever going away. We need our cowboy stories!
Cowboys
Well, I've never met or seen a cowboy but I enjoy reading about them probably because their stories show people and places that I've never encountered.
So much fun
I'm really enjoying all the comments. I wish you could all meet real cowboys, but lots of guys are cowboys at heart, as Kay pointed out. Once again, it's what's under the hat (whatever kind--lots of cowboys wear ball caps, you know) that counts! (And maybe what's in the jeans, too. Ahem.)
Minna--My grandmother was from Finland.
Jeannie
The Horseman's Secret~Harlequin Superromance~Sept 2007
COWBOYS
Cowboys have always had a special appeal for me. When I lived in a large metropolis I never encountered them but I always watched the Westerns during the 1950's and they were my favorite of all programs. Cowboys exhibit a strength, steadfastness and a loyalty which is apparent. I live in the Southwest and encounter many cowboys whose credo is one of high principles and values. Where have all the cowboys gone? I pine for the days of real men and cowboys.
COWBOYS
My favorite of all topics and I can talk for hours about the allure of cowboys. Their strength and determination to achieve goals which are endless. Their courage and backbone to endure difficulties and their own code of honor. I just loved watching Tombstone which is my favorite movie ever.
COWBOYS
Thanks you for this wonderful bog about cowboys. I appreciate it so much. When I think of cowboys I see a hardworking man whose life is devoted to the land and his animals, but is consderate, kind and thoughtful to his fellow man. His work is meaningful and his relationships are important. He is self-reliant but willing to help anyone out. Cowboys are my heroes and have always been able to retain that mystique. Books about cowboys will remain popular forever since they are the ultimate and deserve recognition.
COWBOYS
This is such a dear to my heart blog. Cowboys are real men who can be trusted and I always think highly of these larger than life people. Their manners and civility seems to be from another age when people valued these important attributes. I admire cowboys for their old fashioned values. Books which depict cowboys are my favorites and I hope that these will be around for many years.
Cowboys
My favorite subject!! So much so ~ I married one. It's a way of life, I think. I was born and raised in Oklahoma and after I graduated I was gone. But it wasn't long before I came home.
My cowboy hubby is hardworking and loyal. There isn't a time clock to punch when it comes to animals or crops. You do what has to be done, when it has to be done. He looks good with a tool...even if he doesn't know what he's doing. He'll figure it out or call a friend for advice. If a friend or neighbor needs help...it's not a hand-out but an honor. I love the black hat pulled low but that ball cap is just as sexy. Especially when he's rubbing on his goatee when he's thinking or listening. You're definitely right about dressing to go to town. Those shirts are pressed, good jeans starched so stiff they can stand alone and good boots and buckle are polished. Our wedding...I wore a cream colored dress that looked like an old fashioned southern belle, off the shoulder cap sleeves with corset and petticoats and the guys wore their black hats, boots and black jeans with starched white shirts. But what reeally set it off was the long black duster jackets. They're called "Doc Holliday" jackets. Those that have seen Tombstone will know what I'm talking about.
Honor and respect are so very important to my hubby and even our 13yo opens doors for me. My 4yo is looking pretty handsome in his jeans and boots and may struggle with that door but he'll stand against it until everyone is inside!
But something else ~ he's all about making sure I'm happy. In ALL ways. His favorite saying is "If Momma's not happy...nobody is." He looks like Tim McGraw when he's wearing his black hat...except my hubby's eyes are a gold-green.
Dayum Girlfriend!
Post a photo!!
LOL
ani
Ditto!
What Ani said! LOL!
Photo
You bet! Tell me how! LOL. I've got some on my blog in my June posts from when we had gone to the lake. I'll have to figure out how to scan our wedding picture...
Oh My Gosh!
Chelle, you lucky woman!
Jeannie
The Horseman's Secret~Harlequin Superromance~Sept 2007
Cowboys
I love cowboys! There is nothing finer to see than cowboy butts in tight Wranglers.
I am a city girl who loves a
I am a city girl who loves a good cowboy story...probably because it is so different from my normal everyday life.
Kendra
COWBOYS
When I think of cowboys it is with romantic thoughts but there is also the other side to cowboy lore. The hardships and the stamina and endurance that is necessary to cope with the lifestyle. It is with admiration that I think of cowboys. Even though they are romanticized in novels which is part of the entire attraction, it is a fascinating and enduring part of our culture. Cowboys occupy a real component of our land and without them where would we be? They are portrayed so well in novels and I am glad that there will be more novels since they deserve the accolades.
And the Winner is....
First of all, thanks so much for commenting on my blog. I've loved reading what you have to say and am glad that you think the cowboy is here to stay! You all have excellent insights into the cowboy.
I've decided to have two winners today and they are:
Kendara and Alpha Kitty
Please email me at jeanniewrites at gmail dot com and tell me where to mail your goodies.
Thanks again for commenting and Sam--thanks for inviting me. I had a ball.
Jeannie
The Horseman's Secret~Harlequin Superromance~Sept 2007
YAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
Pammieeeeeeeeeeeeeeee.....my hillbilly friend won...WOOHOO!!!
Actually, I should be protesting, since she has cowboys practically in her backyard;)
Congratulations!!
Way to go Pammie & Kendra!!
Kristen
Way to go!
Way to go, Pammie & Kendra!!!
And one more time....mmmmm, cowboys! :-D
woo hoo!!
WTG Pammie and Kendra!!
ani
Winners
Congrats to the winners!
Congrats!
To the winners!! Enjoy your books!! :)