Are you a listener or a watcher?
When I write, I focus on dialogue because of the way I function in the world. I listen. I believe it’s a survival skill honed from years of teaching junior high. If something is going on, I want to know about it. Kids seem to believe that if your head is down or your back is turned, that your ears shut down. So, I sit and grade, head down, collecting data. Every now and then I may look up and say, “Watch your language,” to a kid in the far corner, which always causes looks of alarm to ripple around the room. The funny thing is, I can say this without having heard any language, but the kids automatically assume that someone must have said something and my teacher radar picked up on it. This generally silences them for almost ten or fifteen seconds.
When I’m in a learning situation, I often close my eyes to focus on the speaker, or I stare at my paper. My kids do the same thing and often got in trouble for not listening in class during their younger years, when in fact, they were probably listening more than the average student. I don’t generally watch TV. I listen to it while doing other things. I love books on tape. The only listening device I don’t like is the telephone. I really freeze up on phones, but other than that I’m a verbal girl.
On the other hand, I am very bad with faces. My husband, who sucks at recognizing voices, is great with faces. We’ll watch a movie and he’ll spot some character actor in full drag, whom he hasn’t seen in a movie in twenty years , and instantly recognize the guy and name all the other movies he’s been in. Sometimes I make a desperate stab at identification, usually by saying something along the lines of “Hey, isn't Will Ferrell doing a great job in this part?” And then my husband will give me the look and say, “No, that’s Paul Newman.” And then I’ll pretend that I knew that all along and was just testing him.
Okay, so I have trouble recognizing faces, not being a watcher, but let them speak and I have them. For example, I was sitting in the living room writing last fall and I heard a voice on the television in the other room. It couldn’t be…not my teenybopper crush, the man I was going to marry someday…I rushed into the TV room. Yes. It was Joe Namath! Whom I hadn’t heard speak in probably fifteen years. He was older, but I did recognize him, having stared at his photos for so long at the age of thirteen that his bone structure is engraved on my memory circuits. And I still thought he looked great. Maybe not quite at hot as my husband, but close. And I also felt great knowing that I could proudly identify him without my husband telling me, “No, that’s Elliot Gould.”
So, are you a watcher or a listener, or a combination of the two? And what do you like when you read? Lots of dialogue or lots of description? (I think it’s a no-brainer as to what I like, lol.)



















It's All in the Body Language
Fun topic, Jeannie! I'm definitely a watcher. I love sitting in a public place and watching people. I tend to be pretty good at reading body language and I infer a lot through facial expressions and hand gestures. Often, it tells me more about what the person is really thinking or feeling, than their words do. I'm not an audio person and nothing makes my eyes drift shut faster than having to listen to someone drone on and on. I have a girlfriend who is a talker, and although I love her dearly, I feel completely drained after a get-together with her. I enjoy a good conversation, but too much listening starts to feel like work.
Karen--I have to admit that
Karen--I have to admit that I may be audio, but I'm also impatient and droners drive me up a wall. This is weird, but I like to listen when people aren't talking to me. Not exactly eavesdropping, but just tuning into surroundings.
Being a watcher, you must love to get into a quiet spot at a party and just observe. What a kick.
My Husband stopped talking to me late at night...
for that very reason. He doesn't drone, but late at night, he talks softly and melodiously and....zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
This REALLLY used to piss him off, lol, but seriously, what was I supposed to do?
Then again, I fall asleep as soon as I'm sitting still. Just bad luck on his part.
The rest of the day, I rely on my eyes, which sucks because my vision is horrible. I'm finding my hearing is off. I can't even tell exactly where the source of a sound is and I'm not totally sure why. But I do hear the differences in modulations really well. Eh. The whole source thing could just be damage from the baby shrieks.
So I guess I'm just a watcher. But oooooh, the things I see!
Dee
Dee-I'm laughing at the
Dee-I'm laughing at the image of your husband talking softly and melodiously to you and you happily snoozing.
Remembering how my ears used to ring after a good shreik at close range, I think the girls may indeed be affecting your hearing.
Have a good one,
Jeannie
Wow
Jeannie, I've never thought about this question. I love silence. I find long conversations exhausting and nothing drains me faster than listening to someone blather on about problems they have no intention of fixing. And when I knit and watch TV at the same time I often feel I've missed something b/c I miss expressions on the actors' faces. So, I can watch "Friends" and knit, but not "The Wire". Guess I'm a watcher?
I like dialogue when I'm reading. Just enough description to set the scene and keep me anchored, then let them talk talk talk!
Margaret
Margaret--I'm diagnosing you
Margaret--I'm diagnosing you as a fifty/fifty listener-watcher. I think droning conversations are especially draining to listeners because they overload the circuit. I know all I think about is escape. My mom used to knit and watch TV. I always wondered how she did it.
Hmm...
Such an interesting post, Jeannie! I'm not sure how to categorize myself... I don't tend to watch too much TV, partly because I don't have time to sit and actually pay attention. If it's a show I don't care too much about, I can give it half-attention while I do something else, like do the dishes. I don't remember how I learned best in school though--I've definitely slept through more than my fair share of lectures... (maybe I'd better not admit that publicly where my kids might someday be able to read this--kids, I NEVER slept through class! I paid full attention, all the time!) I don't know! Probably slightly more of a listener than watcher? I don't do too well identifying people though--it's always sort of a, "hmm... she looks vaguely familiar... I wonder why?"
Fedora,
Lol on NOT sleeping through the lectures. I have that "vaguely familiar, I wonder why" feeling a lot!
I prefer dialogue. So many
I prefer dialogue. So many authors are way too descriptive about the scenery, etc.
Yay, Estella! I like to
Yay, Estella! I like to have just enough detail that I can picture things, but I don't want to know so much that it interfers with the flow of the story.
I'm probably a mixture. I
I'm probably a mixture. I too have to do at least two things at once. I am on the computer when watching (listening) to TV. Every once in a while I look up and surprised at some commerical that I've heard 20 times but just saw for the first time lol. I recognize faces but can't always put a name to them. I'm very verbal but also have an artistic side so if I can get myself to do one thing, I'm a pretty good "watcher."